Showing posts with label report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label report. Show all posts

Saturday, June 21, 2008

Affordable EcoDensity

Making Affordable Housing a Core Principle of Vancouver's EcoDensity Charter

This submission to Vancouver City Council argues that affordable housing must be a central plank of "EcoDensity" on both equity and environmental grounds. The authors question the central premise of EcoDensity that increasing density is tantamount to greater affordability, and call for an EcoDensity Charter that fully articulates a strategy that will ensure an expansion of affordable housing. Without a deliberate, city-wide policy to ensure affordability, existing trends will worsen, leading to adverse impacts on livability and sustainability.

Download the report here

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

Solutions for homelessness offered to City

Three young authors had plenty of advice to offer the City of Vancouver on how to address the growing issues of a lack of affordable housing and a growing homelessness crisis yesterday.

The authors were winners of an essay contest held by Pivot Legal Society that challenged entrants to think outside the box on how to solve one of the most pressing issues facing the City of Vancouver: the future of housing in the Downtown Eastside.

“These essays represent real and pragmatic solutions to homelessness and the future of the Downtown Eastside,” said David Eby, who heads Pivot Legal Society’s Housing Campaign. “But more importantly they represent the possibility that creative thinking and collaboration could help Vancouver solve some pretty challenging problems.”

A panel of high-profile judges, including Cameron Gray of the City of Vancouver Housing Department, Nick Blomley, Professor of Urban Geography at SFU, and developer Robert Brown, evaluated the entries for creative thinking, the practicality of the recommendations, and whether or not the proposals drew from successful models in other jurisdictions.Key proposals from the essays included:

  • A “master lease” program, modeled on a program in San Francisco, where the city pays the capital cost for half of a new build of social housing units, and leases the remaining units from a developer funded by private capital, capital secured by the half of the units paid for by the city. In the alternative, the City could lease existing operating SRO buildings from operators to ensure continued access to those most vulnerable to homelessness. Rents could help offset City costs.
  • A “homeless connect” program, modeled on another San Francisco program, where government and non-government organizations gather in a single location to help homeless people get basic services like replacement identification, eyeglasses and medical care.
  • Employing the recently homeless in building social housing to help build skills and self-esteem.
  • Incorporating economic rights, like a right to housing and a living wage, into our Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
  • Considering the issuing of a special development bond by the City for the benefit of the DTES, where individuals could invest in ensuring socially sustainable and mixed income construction, instead of forcing the City to rely on private investment and developers for revitalization of the area.
Click here to download the report

Friday, April 25, 2008

New Housing Reports

Several new housing reports are now available on the sidebar under the heading Housing, as well as below:

United Nations Special Rapporteur on adequate housing,
Miloon Kothari
Mission to Canada
9– 22 October 2007


Disappearing Homes: The Loss of Affordable Housing in the DTES
(Carnegie community Action Project, April 2008)


Homelessness and Affordable Low Income Housing Backgrounder
(Downtown Eastside Community Land Use Principles Project, September 2007)


The State of Non-Market Housing in the Downtown Eastside
(Downtown Eastside Community Land Use Principles Project, September 2007)

Tuesday, April 8, 2008

2008 Homeless Count - Results

Here are the preliminary reports from the 2008 Homeless Count:

Preliminary Fact Sheet


City of Vancouver - Memo to the Mayor et al

(These reports have are also available under the heading Homelessness on the right sidebar.)

Studies don't support fears of social housing

The vast majority of facilities operate without harming the safety of neighbourhoods or dragging down property values, reports conclude
Lori Culbert, Vancouver Sun
Published: Saturday, April 05, 2008


Crime will go up. Property values will fall. Traffic and noise will increase. My neighbourhood will be less desirable.

They are complaints often made by residents who fear for their families should a halfway house, drug treatment centre, or home for the mentally ill be opened in their community.

They are, perhaps, understandable concerns from people afraid of the unknown.

But are they valid?

With several of these social housing sites either being proposed or recently opened in Metro Vancouver, The Vancouver Sun attempted to research whether these fears have merit.

Academics, city planners and people involved in running these facilities all point to a host of research that shows there is no evidence of crime rates spiking or real estate values plummeting near social housing sites.

A Vancouver city hall study, which analysed 25 years of complaints to city hall and two years of police calls, shows there is no evidence of repeated cries for help near the facilities.

"We found that 71 per cent of the special-needs facilities don't have any single call registered," said social planner Anne Kloppenborg, who wrote the report.

Simon Fraser University professor Julian Somers reviewed multiple research papers that studied the effect of social housing on crime rates and property values -- and concluded there was no effect.

"Things that people might intuitively raise as concerns seem not to materialize," Somers said.

Read the rest here

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Cost of homelessness in millions, report finds

JUSTINE HUNTER
With a report from the Canadian Press
March 24, 2008


VICTORIA -- The federal government could easily bring some relief to B.C.'s homeless population by restoring incentives to the construction industry to build rental housing, the province's Housing Minister said yesterday.

"Governments can't build this stuff fast enough," Rich Coleman said in an interview. "We need tax incentives back in the marketplace to build more rental housing."

Mr. Coleman was responding to a new study that concludes providing shelter for homeless people with severe addictions and mental illness throughout British Columbia could save taxpayers millions of dollars.

The paper, commissioned by Simon Fraser University and released this month, found that providing non-housing services for such people costs the public system more than $55,000 a year per person.

Providing adequate housing and supports could reduce this cost to $37,000 a year, the study found.

It put the cost of failing to act in excess of $200-million each year.

Read the rest here
See also Coleman disputes homeless estimate from the Vancouver Sun

Saturday, March 22, 2008

The high cost of homelessness

Every homeless person costs system $55,000, an amount that could buy supported housing for each of them
Lori Culbert, files from Randy Shore, Vancouver Sun
Published: Friday, March 21, 2008


VANCOUVER - We've been counting them and governments have been scrambling to try to help them, but a recent university study has been looking at a new question about homeless people in B.C. - what each one costs taxpayers a year.

The answer is $55,000 per person, or an annual total of $644.3 million in health, corrections and social services spending for all the homeless in B.C.

But the conclusion of the 150-page report - written by five academics at Simon Fraser University, the University of B.C. and the University of Calgary - is that B.C. taxpayers could even save money if that cash was instead spent directly on supported social housing.

"We wound up generating an estimated cost [of homeless people] in B.C. that is roughly the same as the cost of implementing the full-meal deal of housing and supports for every one of those people," said one of the authors, professor Julian Somers, director of SFU's Centre for Applied Research in Mental Health and Addiction.

The report, completed last month, says its research shows that approximately 130,000 people in B.C. have a severe addiction and/or a mental illness; about 26,500 of those people are "inadequately housed and inadequately supported," including 11,750 who are "absolutely homeless."

Read the rest here

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

New City Data on Housing

Reprinted from David Eby's blog:

Recent data released by the City of Vancouver indicates that market housing growth is far outpacing affordable housing in the DTES. The numbers provide a helpful measure of the change taking place in the neighbourhood, and social housing building overall in Vancouver. Why these numbers aren't more widely available is beyond me.

First, two charts show social housing developments in and outside the DTES, including anticipated timelines. These graphs show approximately 1,557 units over the next 3 to 4 years, suggesting between 400 and 500 new units per year, and well short of the 2,400 units quoted by Coleman in this recent press release and well short of Mayor Sam's absurd claim of more than 3,000 units.

The next graph shows SRO buildings purchased by the province recently, with unit numbers. Anticipated opening dates for buildings not currently in operation are not shown; however, I understand from BC Housing that the renovations will have started on all projects by the Fall.

Of these hotels, all were open and operating except for the Pender, Marr and Rainier hotels, although some were operating at less than full capacity.

Finally, the City is keeping tabs on market housing development in the DTES. This chart shows that 1,597 units have been constructed, are under construction, or are in the final stages of approval for the neighbourhood. This chart does not list the rumoured nine towers that many people in the neighbourhood have heard are under consideration at the City currently.

Finally, the City produced a helpful chart to enable a better understanding of housing trends in the neighbourhood. I apologize for not producing a better version, but this is what I have.

The purple bar reflects non-market housing. The red/burgundy bar shows market housing. The yellowish bar shows SRO/lodging house/residential hotel housing.

A trendline for market housing in the DTES would look like a stock market run in the '80s. A trendline for SRO/lodging house/residential hotel housing would look like a stock market run in the '90s. A trendline for non-market housing would look like a panicked provincial government worried about looking uncaring during the 2010 Olympics, but not really giving much of a crap after that.

Friday, February 22, 2008

Vancouver's Downtown Eastside offers lessons for others: report

Canwest News Service
Thursday, February 21, 2008

VANCOUVER -- With its grimy streets and often abject displays of poverty, misery and drug abuse, Vancouver's Downtown Eastside is a magnet for negative coverage.

But a new report from a Calgary-based think-tank takes an unusually rosy view of the area.

In Lessons from Hastings and Main, the third report in the Canada West Foundation's core challenges initiative, writer Lisa Allford looks at what other Western cities can learn from some of the many programs providing support on the ground in the Downtown Eastside.

What Allford discovered while examining programs as complex as a drug trial offering free heroin and as simple as a non-profit bottle depot, is that good street level programs have at least one thing in common.

"What I learned talking to the few people I did - and they were just a microcosm of the hundreds and hundreds of people working in that neighbourhood - is that what they had is a real respect for the people they work with," she said Wednesday.

"In terms of what makes a worthy program, that's step one."

One such initiative Allford profiled is Sheway, an outreach program for new moms and moms to be in the neighbourhood.

Another program is the United We Can bottle and can depot on Hastings Street. United We Can, started with a small government loan, provides a way for the homeless and drug addicted to earn some legitimate money by bringing in recyclables they can trade for cash.

In the introduction to her report, Allford references "a perfect storm of failed policies" that have contributed to the misery in the Downtown Eastside, Canada's most notorious neighbourhood. And many of those who speak in the report are concerned not just with what programs get funded, but also how.

Link to article
Link to Letters from Hastings and Main: Signs of Hope in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside report

Saturday, February 9, 2008

Minister claims critical housing report is outdated

Policy group claims B.C. spends least on affordable housing
Jonathan Fowlie, Vancouver Sun
Published: Thursday, February 07, 2008


VICTORIA -- A report showing B.C. spends less money per person on affordable housing than any other province is out of date and doesn't count everything the province is doing, Housing Minister Rich Coleman said Wednesday.

The report, released earlier this week by the Wellesley Institute, an Ontario-based policy group, said B.C. spends only $41 per person each year on housing -- well short of the national average of $109 per person, and paltry compared with Saskatchewan's $256.

Coleman, interviewed following a Vancouver meeting of provincial housing ministers, said his ministry's spending has almost tripled in the past 21/2 years and that the report hasn't caught up with reality.

Read the rest here.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Up to 15,500 Homeless: Report

Tally of BC homeless by health profs far higher than housing minister's.
TheTyee.ca
By Andrew MacLeod
January 31, 2008


The number of homeless people in British Columbia may be triple the estimate Housing Minister Rich Coleman provided to The Tyee last week, according to a new report by health professors at UBC, SFU and the University of Calgary.

In B.C. there may be as many as 15,500 adults with severe addictions or mental illness who are homeless, says the 149-page report, Housing and Support for Adults with Severe Addictions and/or Mental Illness in British Columbia. The report is dated October, 2007, and was released to The Tyee on Jan. 30, 2008.

The authors are SFU's Michelle Patterson and Julian Somers, Calgary's Karen McIntosh and Alan Shiell, and UBC's Jim Frankish. The report was prepared at the request of the health ministry's mental health and addictions branch. Other partners and contributors to the report include the provincial health authorities, the Employment and Income Assistance Ministry and Coleman's own Forests and Range Ministry.

To get their estimate, the authors used data and reports from the Canadian Mental Health Association, the Canadian Senate, the provincial government and academic journals. "No single authoritative source of information is available to derive these estimates," the report says. "However, a number of recent reports offered valuable insights into various levels of housing need."

Many at risk

The report says some 130,000 adults in B.C. have severe addictions and/or mental illnesses. About 39,000 are "inadequately housed," meaning they meet the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation's definition of being in "core housing need." Of those, about 26,500 don't have enough support to help them stay in their home.

Somewhere between 8,000 and 15,500 are what the report calls "absolutely homeless," meaning they are living on the streets, couch surfing or otherwise without shelter. The report says the authors confirmed their figures with "local stakeholders and key informants." The report also says that despite impressions that homelessness, mental illness and addiction are urban problems, interviews with front-line workers found the same problems were "highly prevalent in rural settings."

The report's number—which includes only people with severe addictions and mental illness -— far exceeds the figure used by Forest, Range and Housing Minister Rich Coleman. Last week he said there are between 4,500 and 5,500 homeless people in B.C. at any given time. He said the figure came from BC Housing. The agency told The Tyee it based its estimate only on the communities that have done official homelessness counts.

NDP housing critic David Chudnovsky called Coleman's number "bogus." His own "conservative" estimate of 10,500 homeless in the province was made last fall based on homeless counts and numbers provided by shelters and other aid agencies.

High cost status quo

While creating supported housing for everyone at risk of homelessness would be expensive, the authors found the cost of doing nothing is even higher.

"If we focus on the absolutely homeless, non-housing service costs amount to about $644.3 million per year across the province," says the report. That includes the costs to the health care and prison systems as well as emergency shelters. "In other words, the average street homeless adult with SAMI [severe addictions and/or mental illness] in B.C. costs the public system in excess of $55,000 per year."

Providing adequate housing and supports would cut those costs by $18,000 per person each year, it says, saving about $211 million in annual spending.

The authors note they did not include the amount of money that homelessness may cause to be lost by businesses, tourism and cancelled conference or convention bookings. The report says, "The inclusion of these and other cost drivers would further enhance the case for change."

'Key actions' suggested

The report offers a dozen "key actions" that need to be taken to provide housing and support to people with severe addictions and/or mental illness. They include:

* Adopting a "housing first" policy providing permanent, independent homes to people without time limits or requiring residents to get addictions treatment.

* Creating more multidisciplinary treatment teams such as the Assertive Community Teams set to launch Jan. 31 in Victoria. The teams are needed to reach the "hardest to house" and get them better access to services and treatment.

* Taking a "harm reduction" approach at housing facilities and accepting the use of drugs and alcohol on-site.

* Creating more affordable housing and protect the affordable housing that already exists.

* Continuing efforts to make it easier to apply for and receive welfare.

* Hospitals and prisons should set policies so they no longer discharge people with "no fixed address" without knowing where they will go. "No one should be discharged from an institution directly to the street or a shelter without prior arrangement and follow-up."

Finally, the authors recommend immediately building or creating supported housing for the 11,750 or so people with severe addictions and/or mental illness who are already homeless. The number likely underestimates the need, they write, and should be taken as a starting point.

BC Housing's current goal falls far short of the need. The agency's most recent service plan says 1,462 new units of supported housing for homeless people will be added by 2009-2010.

"Without adequate housing and support, people with SAMI who are homeless often cycle through the streets, prisons and jails, and high-cost health care settings such as emergency rooms and psychiatric inpatient units," the Health Ministry's report says. "This is ineffective and costly in both human and financial terms." With help, it adds, they can stay in stable housing. "It is time to implement these evidence-based solutions for British Columbians in need."

Link to the article

Saturday, January 26, 2008

$3.35B needed each year for housing strategy, cities say

Last Updated: Wednesday, January 23, 2008 | 3:44 PM ET
Ottawa needs to put an end to chronic uncertainty about affordable housing and commit to long-term funding for a national housing strategy, the Federation of Canadian Municipalities said Wednesday.

The group, made up of mayors and other municipal representatives, wants to see the federal, provincial and territorial governments invest $3.35 billion annually over the next 10 years into affordable housing and tackling homelessness.

That government has already committed to spending that amount but only up until spring of next year, the federation said. It would like to see the government extend the funding beyond that.

“We are deeply concerned about the upcoming expiry of all federal housing programs in March 2009,” said FCM President and Winnipeg councillor Gord Steeves. “There is no choice. The federal government must put an end to the chronic uncertainty around affordable housing in this country."

In a report released Wednesday morning in Vancouver, the federation outlines a five-pronged national housing strategy.

The report recommends creating about 20,000 new social housing units over the next 10 years.

It also suggests that each year the stock of permanent affordable housing go up by 15 per cent of the total annual housing starts .

The report calls for a reduction in the backlog of those waiting for subsidized housing by 25 per cent over the next decade through methods such as rental assistance and assisted home ownership.

The report notes that about one-third, or 220,000 units, of existing social housing units are at risk of losing their subsidies. It calls for about 20,000 of those units to be modernized and made energy efficient each year so that they remain viable as affordable housing.

Helping senior citizens and those with disabilities stay in their homes by assisting with upgrades to private homes or rental properties is another recommendation in the report. It calls for the improvement of some 10,000 homes.

The federation said it hopes the report will influence the federal, provincial and territorial housing ministers when they meet in Vancouver next month.

Link to article
Link to report (pdf)

Sunday, December 2, 2007

NDP 'shocked' at homelessness numbers across B.C.

By Stuart Hunter, The Province
Published: Saturday, December 01, 2007

The provincial NDP say they're "shocked" and "embarrassed" by a new poll showing there are 10,580 homeless people in B.C.

Party leader Carole James and homelessness critic David Chudnovsky held a news conference on Friday where they announced the poll figures, as well as the creation of a province-wide consultation on the issue called Finding Our Way Home: A Consultation on the Homelessness Crisis in B.C.

"The figure for the province is 10,580 and that is a very, very conservative number," Chudnovsky told The Province. "Shocking is a perfect word to use and embarrassing is a word to use, too."

Chudnovsky, MLA for Vancouver-Kensington, said two things surprised him about homelessness in B.C.

"There were two surprises," Chudnovsky said. "The first is the staggering size of the number, it's shocking. The second surprise is that in B.C. it is a provincial problem - too many people think it is a Downtown Eastside problem."

Chudnovsky said the poll suggests there are about 2,300 homeless living in the Downtown Eastside - about 300 people more than a recent poll done by the city.

Read the rest here

Thursday, November 29, 2007

New Reports

Two new reports have just been added to our General Resources (on the sidebar).

2007 Child Poverty Report Card

The Cost of Easting in BC 2007

The Child Poverty Report Card is produced by First Call. They've come up with an innovative challenge for the Premier:

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

BC's Child Poverty Rate Tops Again

Or is this headline just trying to manipulate you?
By Rob Annandale
The Tyee
Published: November 26, 2007


A new report suggests that one in five B.C. children is poor, making the province’s child poverty rate the highest in Canada for the fourth consecutive year.

At 20.9 per cent, B.C.’s proportion of children living below the poverty line continues to drop from its 2002 peak but is still substantially higher than the 16.8 per cent national average, according to 2005 Statistics Canada data analyzed by First Call: B.C. Child and Youth Advocacy Coalition.

“Other provinces have already announced poverty reduction strategies,” First Call’s Michael Goldberg said in a press release. “It is time for B.C., the province with the worst child poverty rates, to wake up to reality and start taking its responsibilities seriously.”

The report shows Saskatchewan, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland would all fare worse than B.C. if not for higher levels of government assistance.

One important step towards reducing poverty in the province, according to First Call, would be raising the minimum wage from $8 an hour to $10. The report points out that a person working full-time, year-round for the minimum – let alone the $6 training wage – cannot rise above the urban poverty line.

So far, the Liberals have argued that such an increase would be harmful to the booming economy and have blocked opposition efforts on this front.

But the question of raising the minimum wage is not the only politically divisive issue here. The very definition of poverty has become an ideological battlefield and the framing of the problem may have unintended consequences.

Read the rest here

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Miloon Kothari Reports Back



It appears that Mr. Miloon Kothari, the UN's special rapporteur on adequate housing, has had as significant an impact across the country as he had when he visited our squat here in Vancouver last week.
UN to Canada: Take action on housing, homelessness!
Oct 22nd, 2007 by Michael Shapcott
The Wellesley Institute

Canada has received both a sharp reprimand and a strong call to action in the preliminary observations of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Adequate Housing, Miloon Kothari, in his preliminary observations at the end of his fact-finding mission to Canada (October 22, 2007).

The Wellesley Institute was proud to host Mr. Kothari during the Toronto portion of his mission, and we helped to co-ordinate his meetings with non-governmental groups across the country. We'll be posting lots of material from the Canadian mission on the Wellesley web site in the coming days.

The preliminary observations are the first stage towards completing a major review on Canada’s compliance with its international housing rights obligations. Mr. Kothari, who visited five Canadian cities and several Aboriginal communities during his mission from October 9 to 22. He met with senior government officials, representatives of non-governmental organizations and people who are directly experiencing Canada’s nation-wide affordable housing and homelessness crisis.

“Everything I witnessed on this mission confirms the deep and devastating impact of this national crisis on the lives of women, youth, children and men,” said Mr. Kothari. “Canada is one of the richest countries in the world, which makes the prevalence of this crisis all the more striking.”

Mr. Kothari’s preliminary observations are a devastating indictment of almost two decades of funding cuts by governments in Canada, not just of housing programs but also income assistance and other initiatives.
Read the rest here. See also...

Feds urged to draft housing plan
By MEGAN GILLIS, SUN MEDIA

The federal government must launch a national strategy on housing to pull the country out of a decade-old national crisis, the United Nation's special rapporteur on adequate housing said in Ottawa yesterday.

Miloon Kothari visited cities and First Nation territories across Canada to study homelessness and poor housing, the problems faced by women and aboriginals, and the impact the Olympic Games will have on Vancouver.

"Everywhere that I visited in Canada I met people who are homeless and living in inadequate and insecure housing conditions," Kothari said. "On this mission, I heard of hundreds of people who have died as a direct result of Canada's nationwide housing crisis."

The United Nations deems it a "national emergency" when reviewing Canada's compliance with the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Kothari said. Yet Canada has had an annual multi-billion dollar federal budget surplus for almost a decade.

"Everything that I witnessed on this mission confirms the deep and devastating impact of this national crisis on the lives of women, youth, children and men," Kothari said.

Canada once led in progressive housing policies but no longer, since governments have cut budgets, cancelled a national housing program that created 500,000 homes, and slashed income support programs as housing costs spiked, he said.

Kothari recommended that the federal government:

* Start a large-scale plan to build social housing units across the country;

* Renew the Affordable Housing Initiative and National Homelessness Strategy, both set to expire, for the next decade;

* Renew a program that helps low-income people fix up their homes, to combat bed bugs, cockroaches, mice and chronic mould;

* Make sure every household has clean water and proper sanitation when a quarter of aboriginal households now don't;

* Work with the provinces to create a consistent system of tenant protection and rent control.

Kothari didn't just say that Canada has to act to end the crisis, said Mary-Martha Hale of the Alliance to End Homelessness.

HIDDEN PROBLEM

"He also made the point Canada has done this before and has been very successful in providing social housing," Hale said. "Then, in the mid-1990s, it stopped and social assistance rates across the country dropped. That combination has created the problem we have now.

"People working in the field have been speaking up. It's appreciated that an international body has turned a light on just how shocking the situation is here in Canada. There hasn't been a lot of political will."

In Ottawa, Kothari visited Centre 454, the Shepherds of Good Hope and emergency shelters for women and teens.

"I was repeatedly told that those few sanctuaries that are there have to turn people away," Kothari said.

He also heard that gentrification is pricing the poor out of Ottawa neighbourhoods and there isn't a municipal plan to ensure mixed-income neighbourhoods and to protect social housing.

In the capital, the housing "crisis" is less visible than in other cities.

"A lot of the housing crisis is hidden-- the condition of social housing, the density situation of multiple families living in an apartment and the disrepair of buildings that are aging," he said.

"The homeless are out on the street -- there are thousands more who are one step away."

Link to article

UN housing envoy scolds Canadians
`Radical shift in policy' needed to tackle crisis, official warns after visit
Oct 23, 2007 04:30 AM
Ottawa Bureau Chief

OTTAWA–An ambitious national housing program and a strategy to combat poverty is urgently needed to tackle the disaster-like conditions of homelessness and inadequate housing found across the country, a United Nations envoy says.

Miloon Kothari, the UN's special rapporteur on adequate housing, warned yesterday that Canadians are becoming complacent to the crisis unfolding on the streets and that public attitudes could soon mirror the indifference found in the United States.

"What is beginning here has already happened in the U.S., where you speak to people (and) they say, `the homeless are there by choice,' or `it's those drug addicts,'" Kothari said in an interview yesterday. "That is a very serious mental shift."

Kothari ended his two-week visit to Canada yesterday with harsh words for provincial and federal politicians, painting a dramatic picture of a crisis caused by governments' deep funding cuts in the mid-1990s to housing programs and social assistance that once helped impoverished Canadians afford a home.

The result is crowded homeless shelters, tenants living in substandard housing and aboriginal communities without safe drinking water.

"I am very disturbed by the housing situation in Canada," he told a news conference. "The national housing crisis ... needs national attention."

During his visit, he travelled to Toronto, Vancouver, Edmonton and Montreal as well as aboriginal reserves. He visited shelters, talked to housing advocates and reviewed reports. And at the end of his visit yesterday, he questioned how a country like Canada, with its rich surpluses and history of progressive housing policies, had let the housing crisis get so out of hand.

"You have had a history of very progressive housing policies which were summarily abandoned in the mid-'90s, and the consequences of that are here tragically for all of us to see," he said.

"I hope there is a radical shift in government policy," Kothari said.

Coupled with the cuts to government housing programs, Kothari said an "astronomical rise" in house prices has placed rental and ownership housing out of reach for many.

NDP MP Bill Siksay (Burnaby-Douglas), who attended the briefing, said the federal government has stripped the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corp., a Crown corporation, of its mandate to tackle the affordable housing shortage.

Recommendations in Kothari's preliminary report include:

Federal funding and programs for a comprehensive housing strategy, co-ordinated with the provinces. That includes extending Ottawa's affordable housing program, due to expire next year, by another 10 years.

A large-scale initiative to build social housing units and more money to refurbish existing affordable housing.

Special attention and funding to help people on the "margins," such as women, youth, seniors and aboriginals.

A "comprehensive and properly funded" poverty-reduction strategy. "Grossly inadequate" social assistance programs have left many impoverished tenants unable to break the cycle of poverty, he said.

Link to article

Monday, September 24, 2007

BC "boom" not for all

Progress Board reports many people not benefiting.
Dateline: Monday, September 17, 2007
by Marco Procaccini
Straight Goods


The Progress Board released two reports — one in December, one in August — showing that the current "boom" is not benefiting large number of people in BC, as increasing numbers of people are experiencing worsening poverty.

According to the BC Progress Board annual report for 2006, British Columbia is falling behind the rest of Canada on issues like poverty, crime and other social conditions. This despite a government public accounts report Wednesday that showed the province's budget surplus had ballooned to $4.1 billion.

Read the rest here.

Monday, September 10, 2007

Housing - not health care - may be best medicine

ANDRÉ PICARD
PUBLIC HEALTH REPORTER
The Globe and Mail
August 31, 2007


People with severe mental illness often end up on the streets. Conversely, people who end up homeless - usually for financial reasons - are at high risk of being afflicted with mental health problems.

Regardless of their starting point, the homeless mentally ill make far more use of health services such as hospital care and emergency room treatment. This double-barrelled message comes from a new report of the Canadian Institute for Health Information that examines the complex relationship between mental health and homelessness.

Far less complex is the solution, activists and academics say.

"The most obvious solution to homelessness is housing," said Tim Aubry of the Centre for Research on Educational and Community Services and a professor at the University of Ottawa.

He said while this may seem flippant or self-evident, the "housing first" philosophy is just beginning to take root in Canada.

"In this country we invest so much in health care that we often think it's the solution to everything," Dr. Aubry said. "But the best medicine for mental illness is probably housing."

Mary Martha Hale, chairwoman of the Alliance to End Homelessness, agrees. She said people who suffer from mental health problems need stable living conditions in which they can receive support, not the stress and risks of living on the street or in shelters.

Similarly, those who become homeless for economic reasons such as losing their jobs need stability so they can get training, find a new job and avoid a downward spiral of their physical and mental health.

"The answer is housing," Ms. Hale said. "And you know there are social and financial costs to having people living in shelters or on the street that are likely greater than subsidized housing."

The CIHI report, for example, shows that the homeless are big users of health-care services, in particular for treatment of mental health problems.

Specifically, mental disorders (including substance abuse) account for 52 per cent of hospital stays among the homeless, compared to only 5 per cent among the general population.

Similarly, 35 per cent of emergency room visits by the homeless were for treatment of mental disorders, compared to 3 per cent among the general population.

The homeless - and street youth in particular - also have much higher rates of attempted suicide.

"This heavy use of ERs and hospitals reflects just how isolated and marginal homeless people are in their communities," Dr. Aubry said.

Elizabeth Votta, program lead at the Canadian Population Health Initiative of CIHI and one of the report's main authors, said it is important to stress that "not all the homeless are mentally ill and not everyone mentally ill is homeless."

In fact, identifying how many of the homeless suffer from mental illness is difficult. One small study found that almost two-thirds of shelter residents in Toronto had suffered mental health problems in their lifetime. But an Ottawa study found that one-quarter of the homeless were suffering mental health problems.

Even estimating homelessness is difficult, Ms. Votta said. The new report says there are at least 10,000 people living in shelters nightly in Canada, but concedes that that underestimates the true number of homeless people.

Michelle Gold, senior director of policy and programs at the Canadian Mental Health Association, said the report "should serve as a wake-up call around a couple of issues: one, we need to tackle the high rate of poverty among people with serious mental illness and two, we need more affordable, supportive housing."

Article link here.

Saturday, September 1, 2007

Mental disorders leading cause of homeless hospital visits

ANNE-MARIE TOBIN
Canadian Press
August 30, 2007 at 8:23 PM EDT

TORONTO — More than half of hospital stays by homeless Canadians are a direct result of mental disorders, suggests a study of mental health and homelessness released Thursday.

The report by the Canadian Institute for Health Information describes homelessness as a "harsh reality" for more than 10,000 people staying in shelters on any given night in Canada, and provides an overview of research and interventions for people living on the street and in shelters.

In particular, it pulls together hospital data on admissions in 2005-06, and the reasons behind them.

"This is the first time we're tracking this kind of information," Elizabeth Votta, an author of the report, said from Ottawa.

Read the rest here.

Friday, June 29, 2007

Almost paradise
UN report calls Vancouver a 'paradise' city blighted by urban misery of Downtown Eastside
Peter O'Neil, Vancouver Sun
Published: Wednesday, June 27, 2007


OTTAWA - The United Nations today singled out Vancouver as an apparent "paradise" city blighted by a two-kilometre stretch of urban misery.

A grim analysis of the city's drug-drenched Downtown Eastside was included in a report released around the world by the UN Population Fund, which warns of huge social and environmental costs as urban populations skyrocket over the next two decades.
While the report focuses on the growing crisis in large and small cities in underdeveloped countries, Vancouver is one of five cities around the world high profiled as urban areas providing unique examples of urban development.

It describes Vancouver as a "breathtakingly gorgeous" city with a sizzling economy.
"But there is trouble in paradise. And nowhere is it more evident than in the Downtown Eastside-a two-kilometre-square stretch of decaying rooming houses, seedy strip bars and shady pawnshops," states the UN agency.

"Worst of all, it is home to a Hepatitis C (HCV) rate of just below 70 per cent and an HIV prevalence rate of an estimated 30 per cent-the same as Botswana's."

Read the rest here.
Full UN report here.
Addendum:
Vancouver: Prosperity and poverty make for uneasy bedfellows in world’s most ‘liveable’ city here (doc file).